Was Oatly’s trade mark invalid for oat drinks for using the term “milk”? – Supreme Court decision

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

The Supreme Court was recently asked to decide whether Oatly’s UK trade mark no. 03445440  for “POST MILK GENERATION” could remain registered for oat-based dairy substitute food and drink, given that “milk” is a protected designation. Dairy UK, the UK dairy industry trade association, applied to cancel the trade mark for the registered non-dairy food and drink goods (but not for t-shirts).

This was not a more conventional identical or confusingly similar mark dispute between competing brands. Instead, the challenge relied on a ground preventing the registration of a trade mark if or to the extent that its use would be contrary to a law. The relevant law was retained EU legislation (following Brexit) reserving the term “milk” (and other dairy designations) for products derived from mammals.

The Supreme Court dismissed Oatly’s appeal and confirmed that the mark was invalid for the non-dairy food and drink goods. In relation to food and drink goods, the designation of “milk” could only be used in relation to those listed in the relevant EU retained legislation, and oat-based food and drink was not included.

Further, the exception permitting the “milk” designation to be used to “clearly” describe a quality characteristic of a food or drink product (e.g. “milk-free”) was not relevant here. Oatly argued that “POST MILK” signalled that the product did not contain milk. However, the Court considered that it was not clear that the phrase described a product characteristic (e.g. did it mean the product was completely milk-free or low in milk content?). Instead, it appeared to relate to the intended customers (such as younger customers concerned about milk consumption/production) and the mark had been accepted and made sense on t-shirts.  

Key takeaways

  • The risks associated with filing a trade mark should be considered as early as possible during brand development to try to avoid an opposition, cancellation or even a costly rebranding. If you need assistance with your trade mark portfolio, we would be happy to help.
  • Before filing a trade mark, you may decide to conduct a clearance search. However, these checks may need to extend beyond identical or similar trade marks for certain products, particularly food and drinks. Notably, in this case including a protected designation (“milk”) within a longer word mark (in “POST MILK GENERATION”) did not avoid the regulatory restriction.
  • Trade marks are registered for specific goods and services. A mark that is acceptable for t-shirts may not necessarily be registrable for other goods, such as food or drink.
  • Trade marks can be challenged by third parties even after registration. The more usual grounds for challenging a registered trade mark are for it being identical or confusingly similar to an earlier mark or that it has not been used in relation to certain goods/services for a continuous period of five years after registration. Therefore, it is important to use the trade mark for the goods/services registered to reduce the risk of losing such goods/services in a challenge by a third party.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*