
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
When does an agency contract end may seem to be a matter which should not give rise to any issues. However, when it comes to reaching a settlement with an agent following the giving of a no-fault notice of termination, it is a matter which needs to be considered. This was made clear in a recent judgment of the European Court of Justice.
In Kempen Advies Beerse BV v Bank Nagelmackers NV, the European Court decided that an agency contract terminable on notice ends only when the notice period ends. It does not end when the agent receives notice, or when the agent ought reasonably to have become aware that notice has been given.
This is important given that the EU Agents Directive was deliberately drafted so as to prevent principal and agent from derogating, before the agency contract ends, from the provisions governing the agent’s entitlement to indemnity or compensation following termination, where the derogation operates to the agent’s detriment. In other words, the Directive was looking to take account of the fact that, in a principal – agent relationship, the agent is the smaller party and needs to be protected from being pressured into accepting a settlement.
The case arose from three Belgian agency contracts. The principal gave notice of termination. Before all the relevant notice periods had run their course, the parties entered into an agreement dealing with payment in lieu of notice, goodwill indemnity, and additional compensation. The agents later challenged that agreement, contending that it reduced their statutory entitlements at a time when they remained protected by the mandatory provisions of Belgian law. In other words, they had suffered a disadvantage.
The Belgian courts at first instance and on appeal decided that the agents had recovered freedom to agree the level of their claims when they sent the termination notices.
The European Court of Justice took a different view. It decided that the relationship continued throughout the notice period. During that period, the agent remained obliged to perform the contract and continued to depend upon the principal for income generated through the agency.
The fact that notice of termination of the contract has been given – and, as such, the contract’s future has been decided – has no bearing on the agent’s performance. The requirement for the agent to perform the contract during the notice period has been recognised under English law for some years (and in respect of the Commercial Agents Regulations was recognised in Npower Direct Limited v South of Scotland Power Limited where Fox Williams acted for RWE Npower plc and obtained judgment in its favour against its former agent, South of Scotland Power Limited [see here]).
Further Regulation 15 of the Commercial Agents Regulations sets minimum periods of notice for an agency contract of indefinite duration: one month during the first year, two months during the second year, and three months during the third and subsequent years. The parties may agree longer periods, provided that the principal’s period is at least as long as the agent’s. Unless the parties agree otherwise, notice ends at the end of a calendar month.
But Regulation 19 states that the parties may not derogate from Regulations 17 and 18 to the detriment of the commercial agent before the agency contract expires. Regulation 17 gives the agent a right, after termination, to compensation or, where the contract so provides, an indemnity. Regulation 18 identifies circumstances in which that right is excluded.
This can matter to a principal which wishes to achieve an early and final resolution of the agent’s claims. A document described as a settlement agreement, release, or full and final compromise may purport to settle the agent’s rights under Regulation 17. But as was established in the case decided by the European Court, if it is concluded while the notice period remains current, and it provides the agent with less than the Regulations require, Regulation 19 may prevent the relevant provision from taking effect.
Just as there is an obligation on both agent and principal to continue to perform the agency contact in accordance with its terms during the notice period, so the European Court’s reasoning also recognised that the amount payable to an agent may depend upon events during the notice period. An agent may earn commission on transactions concluded during that period. Business produced during that time may also bear on the assessment of an indemnity. Under the compensation model, the value of the agency at the point of termination may reflect the continuing relationship with customers and the commissions likely to have been earned had the agency continued. In addition what happens during the notice period may also impact the agent’s entitlement to post-termination commission.
It follows that a settlement made shortly after service of notice can involve an assessment before the factual position has fully developed.
The decision does not prevent the parties from having discussions during the notice period. A principal and agent can exchange figures, negotiate a proposed settlement, and record the commercial basis on which they expect to resolve matters. The difficulty arises where the proposed settlement agreement is intended to bind the agent immediately in respect of statutory rights from which the parties remain unable to derogate.
A practical approach is to try to agree – on without prejudice and subject to contract basis – the terms during the notice period but make the settlement effective only after the termination date. The contract should identify that date clearly. It should also distinguish payment in lieu of notice, commission, accrued contractual claims and the statutory termination payment. Those items may involve different questions of entitlement and calculation.
Any attempt to settle the agent’s Regulation 17 rights needs to take account of the date on which that relationship actually ends.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields