
Estimated reading time: 3 minutes
An ANN is an AI machine learning model that takes inspiration from the way the human brain is structured by using artificial layered and connected nodes as its ‘neurons’.
The Court of Appeal previously found that Emotional Perception’s ANN for recommending media files (e.g. a song, video or text) by modelling how a user may emotionally respond was not patentable due to falling within the exception for being a computer program “as such” (see our previous article here).
Recently, it was the turn of the Supreme Court to consider this case.
The Supreme Court agreed that the ANN was a computer program.
It held that a computer program included “a set of instructions capable of being followed by a computer…to produce desired manipulations of data” but such results were not necessarily predictable as computers could produce calculations and results that humans could not. Therefore, regardless of whether the ANN was executed through software, embodied in hardware or derived its functioning from training rather than specific programming, it was essentially “a set of instructions to manipulate data in a particular way so as to produce a desired result” and was a computer program.
The next step was to consider whether it was a computer program “as such” to be excluded from patentability.
The Court considered the case law and clarified that the correct approach includes assessing whether the claimed invention has technical features beyond the computer program itself.
The Court noted that the claimed ANN system involved computer hardware on which the ANN operated as well as a database for storing data files, a communications network and a user device. Therefore, it considered that the claim included technical features beyond the computer program.
As the reformulated approach had not been applied before, the Court sent the matter back to the original Hearing Officer of the UKIPO to decide whether the invention could meet the remaining requirements for patentability under the reformulated approach.
The decision has practical implications for businesses developing or protecting AI-driven technology:
Organisations investing in AI-driven technology should reassess both pending and future filings. Our intellectual property team works with technology businesses at all stages of development to structure strong patent strategies aligned with commercial objectives.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields