“Indefinite” does not mean “forever”: Court of Appeal clarifies termination of long-term contracts

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

The Court of Appeal has recently revisited an important issue in contract law: whether an agreement described as continuing “indefinitely” can, in fact, be brought to an end.

In Zaha Hadid Ltd v Zaha Hadid Foundation, the Court confirmed that, as a matter of English law, contracts of indefinite duration will generally be capable of termination on reasonable notice unless the parties have made it unmistakably clear that they intended to create a perpetual arrangement. The judgment provides helpful guidance both on contractual interpretation and on the limits of one-sided termination provisions.

Background

The dispute arose out of a trademark licence granted by Dame Zaha Hadid to her architectural practice. Following her unexpected death, the benefit of the trademarks passed to a foundation, which became the licensor under the agreement.

The licence did not include a fixed end date. Instead, it stated that it would continue “indefinitely”. Over time, tensions developed between the parties, particularly in relation to the financial terms. The licensee sought to terminate the agreement by giving notice, while the foundation argued that the contract could not be terminated at all by the licensee.

The termination clause in the relevant contract included the following language:

“This agreement shall commence on the Effective Date and shall continue indefinitely, unless terminated earlier in accordance with this clause….The Licensor shall have the right to terminate this agreement on giving the Licensee not less than 3 months’ written notice of termination.”

High Court approach

At first instance, the High Court took a strict view of the drafting. It concluded that because the agreement provided termination rights only in favour of the licensor, and described the duration as “indefinite”, the licensee had no ability to bring the contract to an end.

This effectively meant that the licensee was locked into the arrangement permanently, unless the licensor chose to terminate.

Court of Appeal decision

The Court of Appeal disagreed and reversed that outcome, offering a more commercially grounded interpretation.

Indefinite vs perpetual contracts

A central point in the judgment is the distinction between:

  • a contract with no specified end date; and
  • a contract that is intended to last forever.

The Court made clear that these are not the same thing. Simply describing an agreement as “indefinite” does not demonstrate an intention to create an everlasting obligation. However, where no end date is specified, the law will usually assume that the parties did not intend to be bound permanently.

Termination on reasonable notice

Where a contract is of indefinite duration, the default position is that it can be terminated on reasonable notice. This reflects a basic principle of fairness: parties are not lightly assumed to have given up the ability to exit a commercial relationship altogether.

Importantly, the Court treated this as a matter of interpreting the contract as a whole, rather than adding a term artificially. The question is what a reasonable person would understand the agreement to mean in its context.

Effect of one-sided termination clauses

The agreement in this case contained express termination rights, but only for the licensor. The foundation argued that this showed the parties intended to exclude any termination right for the licensee.

The Court rejected that argument. It held that giving one party express rights does not automatically remove any rights that would otherwise arise under the general law. If the parties intend to deprive one side of the ability to terminate, that intention must be clearly spelled out.

In the absence of such clarity, the licensee retained a right to terminate on reasonable notice.

Reasonable notice in practice

The Court agreed that the notice period given by the licensee, being 12 months, was appropriate. What amounts to reasonable notice will always depend on the circumstances, including:

  • the length of the relationship;
  • the scale of financial commitments; and
  • the degree of reliance placed on the arrangement.

Key takeaways

The decision reinforces several practical points:

  • describing a contract as “indefinite” does not prevent termination.
  • English law is reluctant to interpret agreements as perpetual unless that intention is explicit.
  • common law termination rights will generally remain available unless they are clearly excluded.
  • one-sided termination provisions do not, by themselves, remove the other party’s right to terminate.

Practical implications for drafting

For those drafting or reviewing commercial agreements, the case highlights the importance of precision:

  • if a contract is intended to be irrevocable or perpetual, this must be stated in clear terms.
  • if parties want to limit or exclude termination rights, this should be done expressly.
  • if flexibility is desired, it is often better to include a defined notice mechanism, rather than relying on the default position.

This decision brings the law back in line with commercial common sense. Agreements that are silent as to duration will not normally trap parties indefinitely. Instead, the courts will assume that an exit route exists, unless the contract clearly says otherwise.

This is again a reminder to ensure that contract wording is tight and reflects the parties intentions.

You can read the full judgment here.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*