
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
“What is the indemnity to which a terminated agent may be entitled?” is a fair question to ask following recent judgments of the national courts of some EU members states. It is also surprising in that the EU Agents Directive is clear that the indemnity is subject to a cap: it cannot exceed the average of the annual commission earned by the agent in the five years preceding termination or a shorter period of time if the agency has lasted less than five years.
However, last year the Belgian Supreme Court had to reverse an earlier judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal in deciding in favour of the agent that the amount of the indemnity cannot be determined by applying some form of equitable or fair discount to the statutory maximum. Indeed, the Supreme Court noted that the statutory ceiling becomes relevant only when the goodwill indemnity, as calculated in accordance with the relevant legal criteria, exceeds that ceiling.
This was followed by the Spanish Supreme Court deciding in two cases (mistakenly in the view of some commentators) that the amount of the indemnity due to a terminated agent cannot be reduced by a court taking into account criteria such as the volatility of the relevant market, the importance, prestige or recognition of the principal’s brand, or market recognition. However, unless and until the Spanish Supreme Court reverses its decisions, agents whose agency agreements are governed by Spanish law will be in a very comfortable position!
The Commercial Agents Regulations provide, in certain circumstances, a right to an indemnity upon termination of a commercial agency. Although the language of the provision is concise, its application is not. As such, how is the indemnity to be determined?
The starting point is that indemnity is concerned with the value of a benefit which the principal retains after termination. The agent is entitled to indemnity only if and to the extent that the principal continues to derive a substantial benefit from customers introduced by the agent or from increased business with existing customers.
In practical terms, it is often convenient to start with the agent’s commission history. This is because it provides a base from which the relevant elements can be identified and assessed. Commission figures can be broken down by customer and by period. They can therefore be used to identify the relationships which may fall within the scope of the provision and to give an initial indication of their economic significance.
Using that material, the first substantive question is which customers are to be taken into account. The provision is limited to customers whom the agent has brought to the principal or with whom the agent has significantly increased business. The exercise is one of attribution. It requires a careful examination of the part played by the agent in establishing or developing each relationship.
Once the relevant customers have been identified, the next step is to consider whether the principal continues to derive a substantial benefit from them. The emphasis on continuation requires an assessment of the future. The question is whether, and to what extent, those customers are likely to generate business for the principal after termination.
That evaluation will depend on the characteristics of the market and the nature of the customer relationships. Some businesses involve repeat transactions over a prolonged period, while others are more sporadic. Some customers display a high degree of loyalty, while others readily switch suppliers. The assessment must take account of these factors. It must also recognise that the value of a customer relationship is not static. It may diminish over time as circumstances change. The exercise is therefore one of judgment, informed by the available evidence.
The next stage is to place a monetary value on the benefit which the principal is expected to retain. At this point, the commission previously generated by the relevant customers will often provide a useful starting point. It reflects, in broad terms, the level of business which those customers have produced. However, allowance may need to be made for the fact that some customers will be lost and others will reduce their level of activity. The aim is to arrive at a fair estimate of the net benefit which will accrue to the principal.
It is important to recognise that this stage does not produce a precise figure. Indeed, the European Court of Justice has accepted that the determination of indemnity must be “equitable having regard to all the circumstances.” That requirement introduces a further dimension. Even where a monetary value can be attributed to the principal’s continuing benefit, it remains necessary to consider whether that figure should be adjusted in order to achieve a fair result.
Matters such as the duration of the agency, the scale of the agent’s efforts, and the existence of post-termination restrictions may be relevant. The fact that the agent will no longer receive commission from the customers in question will also inform the overall assessment of fairness. The purpose of this stage is not to depart from the principle that the indemnity reflects the principal’s benefit, but to ensure that the outcome accords with the requirement of what is equitable.
The final stage is the application of the statutory cap. The indemnity may not exceed an amount equivalent to one year’s remuneration, calculated by reference to the agent’s average annual remuneration over the preceding five years or, where the relationship has been shorter, over that period. However, as this figure only imposes a maximum on the amount of the indemnity, it is necessary to assess the indemnity by reference to the principal’s continuing benefit and the requirement of equity, and then to compare the resulting figure with the statutory limit. If the assessed indemnity exceeds the cap, it must be reduced. If it is less than the cap, the lower amount will apply.
Whilst the Commercial Agents Regulations provide a right to an indemnity upon termination of a commercial agency, there must be an election to that effect by principal and agent. In default of an election, a terminated agent will be entitled to compensation.
How compensation is to be determined will be the subject of a future agentlaw news.





Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields