Unwritten distribution agreement? What should distributors be thinking about

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Where a long-standing unwritten distribution agreement is ended by the supplier by the giving of notice for convenience – “no breach” notice – the decision in March of the Privy Council in Anheuser-Busch v Commonwealth Brewery provides guidance as to the notice period to be given to the distributor.

In its decision the Privy Council took the view that a notice period of just over 3 months was reasonable in the context of a 40 year relationship as it considered that the distributor was not so dependent on the supplier that a prolonged period was necessary to enable adjustment to its new reality.

The Privy Council emphasised that the purpose of reasonable notice is to enable the distributor to make “alternative arrangements” and to adjust to the loss of the distributorship. In contrast it is not to ensure that the distributor is compensated for such loss. Equally the Privy Council made clear that an argument that there has been a long relationship or there will be a significant loss of future profits does not of itself justify an extended period of notice.

Unsurprisingly therefore the Privy Council rejected the proposition that duration should be translated into notice by reference to any formula, such as a period calculated by reference to years of trading. The suggestion that 1 month’s notice should be given for each year of the relationship was expressly disapproved. The court regarded such an approach as artificial as it failed to address the question that actually arises, which is how long does the distributor reasonably require in order to adjust to the loss of the distributorship?

The position of the distributor

A distributor whose business is structured around a single supplier, and whose operations are closely tied to that supplier’s products, may be able to demonstrate that a longer period is required in order to adjust and make alternative arrangements. Conversely, where the distributor acts for a number of suppliers or has access to substitute products, the court may conclude that a relatively short period is sufficient.

For distributors operating without a written agreement, the implications merit thought.

The absence of a written distribution agreement does not confer flexibility. It introduces uncertainty. The distributor cannot assume that a long history of dealings will translate into a generous period of notice. Nor can it rely on the scale of its anticipated loss as a basis for extending that period. The law does not protect expectations of continuity in this context. It is focused on the issue of transition.

What should distributors do?

A distributor should, if possible, look to put in place a written distribution agreement that provides for an appropriate – longer – period of notice to be given by either party (but essentially the supplier) where it wishes to end the agreement for convenience (as opposed to breach). In doing so the distributor will be reducing reliance on implication. Similarly where the circumstances in which termination of the agreement for breach may occur are identified.

The agreement should also provide for continued performance by both supplier and distributor during the notice period – particularly where notice is given for convenience. If overall continued performance cannot be agreed, then the distributor should look to include an obligation on the supplier to continue supply during the notice period or the right to sell through existing stock or the obligation. By including such provisions uncertain standards are replaced with contractual entitlements.

But what if a written distribution agreement cannot be put in place?

Where a written agreement cannot be achieved, attention needs to turn to the manner in which the relationship is conducted.

The distributor should maintain clear records of the terms on which it operates, including any emails or other communications that may evidence a shared understanding as to:

  • duration;
  • termination; and
  • (if it can be shown) the importance of what is the unwritten distribution agreement to the distributor.

Where the distributor fears that such shared understanding does not exist all may not be lost. But what will be important is for the distributor to carefully lay what is effectively a paper trail to highlight the importance of the unwritten distribution agreement to the distributor.

Even though this material (whether or not a shared understanding exists) will not remove the default rule that the agreement can be ended on reasonable notice for convenience, it can help show the business circumstances that a court will take into account when deciding what length of notice is reasonable so far as the distributor is concerned.

Some commercial issues

Investment decisions require particular care. Expenditure that is closely linked to the supplier’s products may be commercially justified, but it should be undertaken with a clear understanding that the law will not necessarily provide a remedy if the relationship ends. The Privy Council’s analysis makes clear that reasonable notice is not designed to allow the distributor to recoup sunk costs. Accordingly, where significant investment is contemplated, the distributor should seek contractual protection, whether in the form of minimum term commitments, compensation provisions, or agreed notice periods that reflect the scale of the investment.

Operational planning also needs to be carefully considered. The distributor should consider maintaining the ability to adjust its business within a relatively short timeframe – but in doing so recognise that this may influence a court to determine that reasonable notice should be short.

At the same time, the distributor needs to consider the structure of its business. A model that is dependent on a single supplier carries inherent risk. The Privy Council’s reasoning indicates that such dependence may support an argument for a longer notice period, but it does not guarantee it.

Moreover, dependence reduces commercial leverage and increases vulnerability to abrupt change – unless such dependence is reciprocal.

For some distributors it follows that diversification of supply, development of alternative revenue streams, and investment in capabilities that are not tied to a single relationship should be considered. They may serve not only to mitigate the impact of termination but also to strengthen the distributor’s position in any negotiation.

Finally, the distributor should recognise that termination is not a remote contingency. It is an inherent feature of a relationship of indefinite duration. The Privy Council’s decision reinforces the need to approach such relationships with a clear appreciation of that reality.

Take away point

Without a written distribution agreement specifying the period of notice for convenience to be given to the distributor, the law will supply only a term that permits termination on reasonable notice to enable the distributor to adjust. As the Privy Council has made clear that term is confined in its scope. It is concerned with transition, not compensation.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*