The exclusivity trap and how to avoid it

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

The lack of a “step-in” clause

The Commercial Agent’s Regulations provide for a terminated agent to be entitled to either compensation or indemnity (unless the agency agreement is terminated for material breach by the agent). Although it requires an election by the parties, indemnity is often included in an agency agreement for the simple reason that it provides the principal with a degree of certainty as to its exposure on termination of the agency agreement. This is because the agent’s entitlement to indemnity cannot exceed the annual average of the commission earned by the agent over the five years proceeding termination or (if the agreement has lasted for less than five years) then a shorter period of time. Further, our studies have shown that in the case of high performing agents, the way in which compensation is calculated means that indemnity will result in a lower cost for the principal.

However, because it is “backward looking”, the election for indemnity can work to the disadvantage of the principal in a situation where notice is given to the agent. This is as a result of the agent taking the position of how it performs during the notice period (which contractually could be, for example, six months as opposed to the maximum of three months under the Regulations) will be unlikely to make a material difference to the maximum indemnity. Indeed where the agent acts for a number of principals, it may decide that it makes commercial sense for it to devote its energies to the businesses of other principals.

As a result, the principal which has given notice can be faced with a situation where its business in the agent’s territory will stagnate during the notice period. The lack of a “step-in” clause – enabling the principal to intervene in some way in the agent’s exclusive territory – has resulted in the exclusivity trap.

A bad situation can become worse

The Regulations impose on each of the principal and agent an obligation to act dutifully and in good faith. It is also the case that under English common law an agent owes a fiduciary duty to its principal: in essence a duty to put the principal’s interest before that of the agent and the interests of other principals for which the agent acts.

But it is one thing for this obligation and duty to exist, it is another for the agent to found to be in breach of either or both of them. As such during the notice period the agent may have covert meetings with one or more of the principal’s competitors leading to the agent entering into a new agency agreement to start upon the expiry of the notice period.

Such action by the agent may be supported by adverse behaviours. For example, knowing that a customer in its territory may be about to place a major order or make a long term commitment, would it be so difficult for the agent to encourage the customer to delay?

How to avoid the exclusivity trap

Avoidance can take any one or more of three forms:

  • The principal needs to remain alert. Changes in the agent’s behaviour or rumours in the market may act as a catalyst for the principal to start asking questions of the agent. If asked a question, the agent must answer honestly. If the agent is found to have lied, the principal will be justified in terminating the agency agreement immediately (and irrespective of the notice period still to run) and the entitlement of the agent to indemnity will be lost.
  • The Regulations impose an obligation on the agent to comply with the reasonable instructions given by the principal. Failure to do so may result in the agent committing a serious breach of the agency agreement. In turn this will entitle the principal to accept the breach as bringing the agency agreement to an end and again the entitlement of the agent to indemnity will be lost.

This is the essence of performance management. The fact that the notice period is running does not affect the obligation of the agent under the Regulations to comply with the principal’s reasonable instructions.

As such whether or not the principal has “managed” the agent before notice of termination was given, the principal should look to do so during the notice period!

  • Thought should be given before the agent is first appointed by the principal to including in the agency agreement a post-termination restriction not to act for competitors post-termination. The Regulations require that such a restriction must relate to the territory or group of customers and the territory entrusted to the agent and to the kind of goods covered by the agency under the agency agreement. In addition the restriction cannot last for more than two years after the termination of the agency agreement. Further the restriction must be considered to be reasonable under English law. However, by including an appropriate non-compete restriction in the agency agreement, the principal may effectively force the agent to focus on performing the agency during the notice period.

Final thought

A “step-in” clause can take various forms. It can allow the principal to:

  • directly contact customers; or
  • require the agent to be “shadowed” by:
    • an agent which has been appointed by the principal to succeed the terminated agent; or
    • an employee of the principal.

By including a “step-in” clause in the agency agreement, the principal should be able to have the benefit of performance by the agent throughout the duration of the agency agreement and not just for the period before the notice of termination was given.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*