AML compliance – key pitfalls for law firms and how to avoid them

Estimated reading time: 11 minutes

Despite the SRA’s ongoing scrutiny and enforcement action on anti-money laundering (“AML”) compliance, recent research has painted a concerning picture of the legal sector’s ability to comply. 

According a the report produced by Thirdfort, which is based on input from over 150 senior compliance leaders, many firms still struggle to operationalise effective AML systems.  This is in part due to a lack of respect or understanding within the firm of the role and responsibilities of the compliance team – with 51% of respondents saying that compliance is not respected within their firm – and also thanks to a lack of resourcing for the compliance function. 

In recent enforcement actions, the SRA has levied significant fines on firms for failure to comply with the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (the “AML Regulations”).  The SRA’s outgoing Chief Executive Paul Philip has suggested that the enforcement action will continue, with a target of 700 inspections in the current practising year.  Philip noted that inspections are still uncovering basic deficiencies in law firms’ AML arrangements, largely due to lack of attention or lack of capacity. 

Firms should therefore act now to ensure they are fully compliant with the AML Regulations.   

In this article we discuss the key pitfalls for law firms in AML compliance and practical steps to avoid them.  We cover:

  1. What are the main AML deficiencies?
  2. What are the consequences of getting it wrong?
  3. If we identify a breach of the AML Regulations, do we need to self-report to the SRA?
  4. Practical steps

1. What are the main AML deficiencies?

There are many detailed requirements set out in the AML Regulations and therefore myriad ways in which a firm can fail, but there are a number of common themes emerging from SRA enforcement action and matters encountered in practice:

a. Inadequate firm-wide risk assessments (“FWRAs”) (or sometimes no risk assessment at all): A risk-based approach is inherent in the AML Regulations, which recognise that it is not a matter of one size fits all.  A firm’s FWRA must be tailored to its business and the nature of its clients and services and regularly updated.   

b. Insufficient client due diligence (“CDD”): CDD requirements extend beyond simply verifying the ID of the client and/or its beneficial owners.  Source of funds and source of wealth checks, which are a fundamental part of CDD, may sometimes be lacking, particularly where CDD is treated merely as a tick-box exercise which gets in the way of starting work on a new matter. 

c. Weak ongoing monitoring and record-keeping: The need to conduct ongoing monitoring of business relationships, as required under Regulation 28(11), is a particularly difficult obligation to discharge in practice.  Many firms have not adequately considered the systems and controls which they can use to assist with meeting their obligations.

d. Failure to remain up to date with changes to the AML Regulations: This is a very common issue.  The requirements of the AML Regulations change frequently, and it is all too easy for these to be missed, particularly when client work is demanding. These changes include, for example, amendments to the list of High-Risk Third Countries, additional risk assessment requirements (new technologies, proliferation financing), verification of statutory registers, politically exposed persons (PEPs) and the duty to report discrepancies in information provided by the client.   

e. Failure to provide training to staff: Regulation 24 requires a firm to “take appropriate measures” to ensure that “relevant employees” (a poorly defined term which should be given a broad interpretation) are (a) made aware of the law on money laundering, terrorist financing and proliferation financing (along with applicable data protection requirements) and (b) regularly given training in how to recognise and deal with transactions and other activities or situations which may be related to them.  Training must therefore be given periodically, as is appropriate to the firm and its practice and aligned with updates and changes to the FWRA.

f. Failure to register with the SRA: SRA-regulated firms are required to inform the SRA if and when they start (or stop) carrying on work within scope of the AML Regulations and, where they are, they must register all of the firm’s beneficial owners, officers and managers (“BOOMs”) with the SRA along with a DBS or criminal records check for each.  However, this is sometimes neglected.  BOOMs – a broader scope of individuals than simply partners – should be approved by the SRA before they are appointed to their role, and it is a criminal offence under the AML Regulations to fail to do so.       

g. Confusion over the scope of the AML Regulations: Not all legal services will be within scope of the AML Regulations.  A firm which does not engage in transactional work, such as an employment or litigation boutique, may be thought out of scope, but it is not only real estate or M&A or other financial transactions which are caught.  Those giving tax advice or trust and company services will also be caught.  In any case, the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and other legislation applies to all businesses, whether caught by the AML Regulations or not.

2. What are the consequences of getting it wrong?

The SRA has continued to impose significant fines for breaches of the AML Regulations, either via an internal adjudication or enforcement via the SDT.  These are based on the firm’s UK-based turnover and can be significant. 

The financial penalties are likely to increase, with the SRA recently undertaking a consultation on financial penalties, although it has (for now) ruled out measuring this with reference to global as opposed to domestic revenues, which would be significant for international law firms.

3. If we identify a breach of the AML Regulations, do we need to self-report to the SRA?

The AML Regulations are a separate regime from the SRA’s Codes of Conduct.  The Regulations apply to some – but not all – law firms and to many other types of business.  However, the SRA treats breaches of the AML Regulations as breaches of the SRA Code of Conduct, or at least the 2011 Code of Conduct, which is now superseded. 

This is a central issue in the SRA v Dentons case, which was reversed at the High Court in the SRA’s favour and remitted to the SDT.  In Dentons, the High Court held that the firm had breached Outcome 7.5 of the Code of Conduct 2011, which requires firms to “comply with legislation applicable to your business, including anti-money laundering and data protection legislation”. 

However, it is not clear that the same analysis applies for breaches under the current SRA Codes of Conduct, which were introduced in 2019.  The most similar obligation in the 2019 regulations is the duty in the Code of Conduct for Firms to “have effective governance structures, arrangements, systems and controls in place that ensure…you comply with all the SRA’s regulatory arrangements, as well as with other regulatory and legislative requirements, which apply to you”. 

A minor breach of the AML Regulations, or perhaps one which is not centrally an issue of systems and controls, might not be sufficiently serious to report to the SRA, but it should still be recorded internally.        

However, the SRA is clear that firms should err on the side of caution and, if in doubt, report the matter. 

This is nevertheless not generally what we see in practice.  Most regulatory and disciplinary action which the SRA takes in relation to AML compliance failures arises from its discoveries in the course of desk-based reviews and on-site inspections.

4. Practical steps

The AML Regulations are wide-ranging and complex and there are many ways in which a firm can fail to comply.  However, there are a number of practical steps and principles which all firms should take on board to ensure they are compliant:    

a. Revisit your FWRA frequently: This should be annually and in any case upon the arrival or departure of any partner (at least for small firms) or practice group, in case the changes to the practice requires an update to the risk profile of the business and/or the split between in-scope work and that which is out of scope.

b. Keep abreast of changes: The SRA’s compliance update emails are a useful service for this.  It is important to consider at an early stage whether, and to what extent, changes to the regulations will impact your firm and what needs to change as a result.   

c. Ensure that policies are tailored to the FWRA: Too often these are not bespoke to the firm’s practice areas and other matters which should be identified in the FWRA. One of the key things that SRA inspections focus on is to test whether the policies are tailored to the firm and whether they are reflected “on the ground” through file reviews and staff interviews.

d. Appoint a Money Laundering Compliance Officer (MLCO): The AML Regulations require the appointment of a board member or senior manager as the officer responsible for the firm’s compliance with the AML Regulations, generally known as a Money Laundering Compliance Officer, where this is “appropriate to the size and nature of the business”.  The SRA’s view is that appointing an MLCO is likely to be appropriate in the “vast majority” of cases, and may not be necessary only in limited circumstances, for example sole practices or firms which only carry out in-scope work on a very occasional basis. The MLCO role is in in addition to the Money Laundering Reporting Officer (MLRO). The MLRO is responsible for receiving internal suspicious activity reports, assessing them, and making external reports to the NCA when appropriate. The MLCO (Money Laundering Compliance Officer) is responsible for ensuring the firm’s overall compliance with AML regulations — overseeing policies, procedures, training, monitoring, and regulatory liaison.

e. Document your decisions: The extent of many obligations under the AML Regulations are variable in their scope depending on the size and nature of the firm’s business.  For example, it is unlikely to be appropriate for a small firm which does minimal in-scope work and low value transactions to appoint external specialists to carry out detailed audits on an annual basis.  As the LSAG guidance makes clear: “If in doubt, write it down”. 

f. Record your reviews: Firms should keep a log of all reviews conducted, including the FWRA, reviews of policies, controls and procedures, ongoing monitoring of client relationships and others.     

g. Scrutinise new products and technologies: This might include AI-based tools, ID verification measures, and any other technologies or practices which you introduce to your services.  These must be risk-assessed, and measures must be taken to mitigate any money laundering or terrorist financing risks which are posed.  

h. Consider whether a “one size fits all” approach to CDD is appropriate: A common approach to compliance with the CDD requirements set out in the AML Regulations has been for a full-service law firm to treat all matters as falling within scope of the regulated sector.  However, we are increasingly seeing a shift which is more reflective of a risk-based approach, in which the firm adopts a lighter touch for matters outside of scope of the AML Regulations, so as to devote more resource to those which are within the regulated sector.     

i. Don’t neglect training: This is a particular focus of the SRA currently.  Failure to train staff limits the firm’s ability to detect money laundering and can diminish the effectiveness of AML policies.  Consider targeted sessions for partners and/or higher-risk practice areas such as real estate.  

j. Don’t “file it and forget it”:  CDD is not a one-off process. AML is a matters-based regime and CDD should be reviewed when new matters are opened and where appropriate refresh of CDD should be diarised and client behaviour should be monitored for unusual activity throughout the matter.  Reviews and updates to the risk assessment for a client or matter should be fully recorded. 

Contact us

If you have any questions about these issues in relation to your own organisation, please contact a member of the professional services team or speak to your usual Fox Williams contact.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*