Lessons for employers from Clyde & Co v Jalan: global mobility meets local law

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

The recent case of Clyde & Co LLP v Jalan [2026] EWHC 403 – a case in which Fox Williams advised the successful party – provides a timely reminder of several core employment law principles that remain highly relevant for UK-employers with staff based abroad.

1. Claims are usually brought where the employee lives and works

Employment disputes are typically determined in the jurisdiction where the employee lives and works. This reflects both practical reality and public policy: local courts and tribunals are generally best placed to adjudicate disputes arising from work performed in their territory.

In Clyde & Co v Jalan, Mr Jalan was a corporate lawyer who lived and worked in Dubai. He was employed by a London-based law firm under a complex suite of documents, some of which stated that they were governed by UAE law. Some of those documents also contained a clause which purported to require that any dispute between the parties was to be resolved by arbitration in London.

Following a pay dispute, Mr Jalan commenced proceedings in the Dubai Labour Court under UAE law. Clyde & Co sought an “anti-suit injunction” in an effort to force Mr Jalan to arbitrate the dispute in London rather than pursue his claim in Dubai. The English High Court refused to restrain the Dubai proceedings, with the Judge observing that the London firm could “hardly complain” about the Dubai-based employee litigating in his place of employment in accordance with local law.

For employers, this reinforces a key point: employees will normally be entitled to bring employment claims in the courts closest to their place of work, and it can be difficult to force claims to be heard in the country in which the employer is based or headquartered unless those courts and laws have a much closer connection.

2. Contractual complexity and inconsistency create risk

The case also highlights the risks that can arise where an international employment relationship is governed by multiple, overlapping documents. In Clyde & Co v Jalan, the employer relied on a suite of agreements pointing in different directions—some suggesting London arbitration, others (including local statutory documentation) pointing clearly to UAE law and jurisdiction.

For HR professionals, the key lesson is that inconsistency across contractual documents can significantly undermine an employer’s intended legal protections. Local statutory contracts -particularly in jurisdictions with mandatory employment frameworks – may take precedence over global or centrally drafted terms. Where documents are not properly aligned, provisions such as arbitration clauses or governing law clauses may be difficult to enforce, or disregarded altogether.

Employers operating internationally should therefore ensure that all employment-related documentation (including local contracts, side letters and partnership-style agreements) is consistent, up-to-date and reflects the reality of the working arrangement in the relevant jurisdiction.

3. The employment contract cannot be used to stop Tribunal claims

A related principle is that employers cannot use “dispute resolution clauses” in their employment contracts to force UK-based employees to resolve employment disputes outside of the Tribunal system, a settlement agreement or via ACAS / a COT3.

This is consistent with a broader trend: regardless of what the contract says, mandatory employment laws (such as minimum pay, termination rights, and holiday entitlement) will usually apply if the employee is working in that jurisdiction.

4. Labels such as “partner” or “director” are not determinative

Another important takeaway is that titles do not determine employment status.

Despite being labelled a “partner”, the court noted that Clyde had “deliberately chosen to make Mr Jalan an employee and not a partner” in Dubai. This distinction was critical in applying UAE labour law protections.

This reflects a familiar issue in UK law: individuals described as “partners” or “directors” may in reality be employees or workers, depending on the substance of the relationship. Similarly, holding the title of “director” does not automatically mean that fiduciary duties are owed in the same way as for statutory directors.

5. Litigation strategy and conduct carry reputational risk

Finally, the case highlights the reputational consequences of how disputes are handled.

The High Court was openly critical of Clyde & Co’s conduct towards its employee, calling it “extraordinary”. The judge described aspects of its approach as “unreasonably pressurising” and “verging on bullying”, including withholding remuneration and raising performance concerns after the dispute arose. Although Clyde & Co sought to keep the judgment confidential, the Court dismissed this on the basis of public interest, meaning that these criticisms are now on the public record.

These criticisms have been widely reported in the legal press, illustrating how litigation strategy can quickly become a matter of public scrutiny and cause a PR-headache for employers.

Key takeaways for employers

  1. Expect employment claims to be brought in the employee’s working jurisdiction.
  2. Do not assume contractual provisions can override mandatory local employment laws.
  3. Remember that titles (partner, director) might not accurately reflect legal status.
  4. Consider reputational as well as legal risk when managing disputes. Threatening employees to drop their claims or face consequences at work is unlikely to reflect well with the judiciary.

For international employers, the message is clear: global structures do not displace local employment rights—and missteps can have both legal and public consequences.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*