Speaking truth to Meta: what the “whistleblowers” teach UK employers

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Global technology conglomerate Meta recently agreed to pay up to $18 billion and make significant changes to Facebook and Instagram, following US-state claims concerning the effect of its platforms on children. The states alleged that Meta designed addictive products, exposed children to harm and misled the public about the risks. Meta denied wrongdoing. The claims were assisted by Meta staff “blowing the whistle” about the company’s internal knowledge of product risks.

As part of a three-part series, we are also examining the Meta settlement through the lenses of:

The UK whistleblowing framework did not apply to the recent Meta legal proceedings. However, the evidence given by the individuals who appear to have effectively “blown the whistle” brought Meta’s research and practices to regulatory and public attention.

Today, we consider what protection UK employees might have received had they raised the same concerns under the UK framework. Along with the practical take aways for UK employers.

What did the Meta whistleblowers disclose?

Several former Meta employees raised child-safety concerns.

In 2021, Frances Haugen disclosed internal documents to the US Securities and Exchange Commission and Congress, alleging that Meta knew its products created risks for children and other users.

Overview of the UK whistleblowing regime

UK employees and workers are protected by statute from detriment by their employer for making a relevant “protected disclosure”.

The disclosure must first be “qualifying”: it must disclose information, rather than merely gather evidence or threaten disclosure; and concern one of the following:   

  1. A criminal offence.
  2. Breach of any legal obligation.
  3. Miscarriage of justice.
  4. Danger to the health and safety of any individual.
  5. Damage to the environment.
  6. Sexual harassment.
  7. The deliberate concealing of information about any of the above.

The individual must reasonably believe that the information tends to show the relevant failure and that disclosure is in the public interest.

The qualifying disclosure then becomes “protected” where it is made in a prescribed way, including to the employer, the person responsible for the failure or in the course of obtaining legal advice.

Would the concerns amount to protected disclosures?

An individual need not call their communication whistleblowing or refer to the legislation. However, general disagreement or dissatisfaction may be insufficient.

Detailed research, user statistics and information about what senior management had been told would be likely to meet that requirement. The disclosures attributed to Béjar and Haugen were much more specific than a general allegation that Meta’s platforms were unsafe.

The alleged wrongdoing in Meta’s case could fall within several statutory categories, including a danger to health and safety and a breach of legal obligations.

It is also important to consider that the individual would not need to prove the allegation was correct to obtain UK legal protection.

The disclosures would be likely to be considered in the public interest given risks affecting large numbers of children have an obvious public dimension. Relevant factors include the seriousness of the harm, numbers affected, the organisation’s scale and the nature of the alleged wrongdoing, particularly if systemic or deliberate.

Who received the disclosures?

A qualifying internal disclosure will ordinarily be protected. However, protection may apply to a disclosure to an appropriate prescribed regulator. In a UK version of parallel events, relevant bodies might include Ofcom or the Information Commissioner’s Office. The individual must reasonably believe that the issue falls within the regulator’s remit and that the information and allegations are substantially true.

Disclosure to journalists, the public or a non-prescribed body is more difficult. One of the key points is that the individual generally needs to show that disclosure was reasonable, that they reasonably believed the information was substantially true and that it was not for personal gain (together with other conditions). UK law does not invariably require internal procedures to be exhausted, but the chosen route is legally significant. Therefore, Haugen’s disclosures to the Wall Street Journal and others would require separate assessment.

Confidential documents and the manner of disclosure

Importantly, whistleblowing protection does not offer a general licence to extract or publish confidential material. Removing personal data, privileged documents or substantial quantities of unrelated material may create separate legal issues. A disclosure will not qualify if making it involves an offence.

Employees also need to be aware of the scope of the protection; an employer remains able to take action for misconduct that is genuinely separate from the disclosure, including potentially the way the information has been disclosed. However, employers should approach that distinction with caution.  

What if the whistleblower is monitored or dismissed?

Workers have the right not to suffer detriment because they made a protected disclosure. This may include removal of responsibilities, exclusion from meetings, obstruction of work, heightened scrutiny or damage to career prospects.

Employees are also protected from automatic unfair dismissal where whistleblowing is the sole or principal reason for dismissal. Compensation is uncapped.

The alleged “reorganisations” applicable to DeFriez and Sevedge are useful to unpack. In the UK, it is likely that a tribunal would examine when the restructure was planned, who selected the employees, what they knew about the disclosures, whether comparable employees were retained and whether there was a genuine reduction in work. Strong performance and suspicious timing are very likely to be considered relevant evidence.

What are key whistleblowing takeaways for UK employers?

  • Always assess the substance of a concern, rather than whether the individual uses the word “whistleblowing”.
  • Maintain an up to date and usable whistleblowing policy that directs employees on how to raise concerns effectively internally and includes simple explanations of whistleblowing law/protection.
  • Manage personal grievances distinctly from public-interest concerns, while recognising that a communication qualifying as whistleblowing may contain both.
  • Ensure redundancy, performance and disciplinary processes/decisions are not conflated with concerns raised by the individual that could potentially constitute whistleblowing. This may include ensuring separate people/teams investigate different issues.
  • Preserve evidence and consider independent investigation where appropriate, to support arguments that whistleblowing concerns have been properly managed.
  • Develop and follow an agreed process/plan for regular IT investigations and checks at defined intervals, rather than running spot searches, which could be viewed as attempts to identify and penalise whistleblowers.
  • Ensure confidentiality clauses, settlement agreements and policies include appropriate protected-disclosure carve-outs.
  • Provide alternative reporting routes where concerns involve senior management.
Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*