
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
How important are instore sales for your brand? Would a concession be attractive? The issue is that a concession is not a smaller shop within a larger one where you enter into a tenancy agreement with the landlord. Instead it is a contractual arrangement that allocates control, risk, revenue and customer relationships between two independent businesses.
So what are the issues?
Most concession arrangements will be licences, rather than leases. The retailer will normally retain control of the premises, reserve rights to enter, relocate the concession, and alter the wider trading environment including brand adjacencies. The brand commonly has no right to remain in the same space. Nor will it enjoy the statutory renewal protection which a business tenant would have.
A concession proposal should identify the initial area, trading hours, access rights, storage, staff facilities, services and the extent of the retailer’s right to move the brand. A broad relocation right may be necessary for a changing store layout, but the brand should seek appropriate limits: a comparable location, reasonable notice, retailer-funded move costs and a right to terminate if the replacement space materially damages the concession’s prospects.
A concession will involve more than agreeing a commission percentage on sales. Commission will be calculated on “net sales” or “net receipts” but what is meant by these terms is critical. The concession agreement should specify the treatment of VAT, refunds, discounts, staff purchases, loyalty points, gift cards, delivery charges, marketplace sales, chargebacks and fraudulent transactions.
Usually sales will be made by the store and not the brand. But in this case the brand will need timely, auditable sales information, clear payment dates, and a process for resolving discrepancies. Service charges, card fees, marketing contributions, shrinkage and insurance contributions should be separately identified.
Minimum sales thresholds, if included, should state how they are measured, when they can trigger action, and whether they are adjusted for closures, refurbishment, relocation or disruption beyond the brand’s control.
Who owns stock until sale? Who bears the loss if products are stolen, damaged or incorrectly discounted? Is the retailer selling goods as principal, or acting for the brand? The answer affects invoicing, VAT, returns, consumer communications, product recalls and liability. The concession agreement therefore needs to specify who sets retail prices (but see below), authorises promotions, and accepts returns.
Invariably the brand will wish to retain pricing and promotion discretion. Where this does not happen (for example, the store is undertaking a Black Friday promotion and all brands are required to take part) competition law issues arise. What is the case that the store and brand use the concession agreement to disguise unlawful resale-price maintenance or other restrictions of competition at their peril.
Controls over online sales, use of the retailer’s name, local advertising and competing nearby outlets should be no wider than the commercial arrangement requires.
Staffing produces risks that are easy to overlook. The brand will usually employ staff engaged at the concession, remain responsible for pay, working time, disciplinary action and employment claims, and require staff to observe the store’s operational policies. Yet the store will frequently set training, security, safety, dress and conduct requirements and may seek the right to exclude an individual from its premises. That right should be exercised for stated, reasonable grounds. In particular, an instruction that effectively demands dismissal may leave the brand exposed to a claim.
The store may also owe duties to individuals supplied to work at its store as contract workers under the Equality Act 2010. Indemnities should not make the brand bear losses resulting from the store’s discriminatory or unlawful conduct.
A sale through the concession will often generate customer contact details, purchase history, returns data and loyalty-programme information.
The concession agreement needs to state which party is controller for each purpose, whether either acts as processor, what customer-facing privacy information is required, and whether data can be shared for marketing.
Where one party processes personal data only for the other, the written terms must contain the UK GDPR requirements for controller–processor arrangements. A data-sharing arrangement between independent controllers requires a different analysis, including an appropriate lawful basis and transparent privacy information.
Insurance, liability and indemnities should be read as a package. The brand may appropriately insure stock, employers’ liability and product liability. It should resist an unlimited indemnity for every claim connected with the concession, particularly where the store controls the premises, tills, security or customer communications. Liability caps, exclusions for indirect loss and obligations to mitigate should be considered alongside the insurance programme, not after it.
The issue of termination calls into question issues concerning the length of the term, renewal mechanism, break rights, notice periods, immediate-termination events and any cure period for remediable breach which should be addressed in the concession agreement.
The agreement should deal expressly with stock take, unsold stock, removal of fixtures, customer orders, gift cards, data return or deletion, final commission statements and access for decommissioning. It follows that records of sales, complaints, operational requests and agreed variations should be kept throughout. They are valuable for managing the relationship and indispensable if its ending becomes contentious.
A concession can give a brand a compelling retail presence. Its value, however, can easily be affected by the allocation of rights and responsibilities in the concession agreement.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields