
Estimated reading time: 12 minutes
Members of the Fox Williams financial services regulatory and employment teams have been reviewing the latest proposed developments in relation to SM&CR and reflecting on what these would mean for firms and individuals in the sector.
On 22 October 2026, the FCA published CP26/37, setting out Phase 2 of its review of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR). At the same time, the PRA published CP14/26.
Building on the Phase 1 reforms introduced in April 2026, Phase 2 aims to reduce complexity and cost while preserving accountability. The FCA estimates annual compliance expenditures could fall by £229m (around 53%) from an estimated £434.5m.
These are consultation proposals, not final rules. Some of the more significant changes also depend on the Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 becoming law, which would give the FCA and PRA greater flexibility to set SM&CR requirements.
The consultations close on 22 January 2027. Dual-regulated firms will need to consider both the FCA’s CP26/37 and the PRA’s CP14/26. Final rules are expected in H1 2027, with implementation provisionally anticipated in H2 2027. If the proposed changes go through, firms will need to ensure that their business lines are aware of the implications, and that Risk, Compliance, Legal and HR teams and functions update their internal policies and procedures accordingly. The proposals also raise wider cultural issues for firms to consider in terms of accountability and conduct.
The consultation papers are lengthy (for example, the FCA’s consultation paper runs to 73 pages, with an additional 352 pages of draft Handbook text, and invites responses to 27 questions). The update below is therefore a broad summary – should you have specific questions, please reach out to your usual Fox Williams contact or one of the authors of this update. The regulators’ webpages include details explaining how to respond to the consultations.
| Area | Key proposals |
| Certification and Directory | The Certification Regime and FCA Directory of Certified and assessed persons would be removed. For CRR and Solvency II firms, the PRA proposes extending its competent-employee rule to expressly cover honesty and integrity. |
| Regulatory references | Regulatory references would no longer be required for staff certified under the current SM&CR, but would remain for SMF applicants, including notified roles. |
| Conduct Rules | The FCA would retain the rules, but replace mandatory training with a duty on firms to tell each person which rules apply to them. For staff subject only to the Individual Conduct Rules (ICRs), it also proposes narrower reporting thresholds and a 14-month deadline for reporting final disciplinary outcomes (after any appeal). |
| Senior Manager appointments | Certain roles, which currently require regulatory approval under the current SM&CR would become notification-only. This includes the FCA’s SMF 5 and SMF10-15 and a broader list for the PRA, including SMF 6 and SMF7a. The FCA would also remove SMF18 and SMF22, and narrow the scope of SMF7 for solo-regulated firms. |
| Prescribed Responsibilities | The FCA would remove nine Prescribed Responsibilities, retaining three for Core and Enhanced firms, plus one additional responsibility for relevant Enhanced firms. |
| SoRs and MRMs | Updated SoRs and MRMs would no longer need to be filed with regulators routinely when responsibilities change; Form J would be removed. |
| Temporary SMF cover | Both regulators would extend temporary SMF cover from 12 to 18 weeks.The FCA proposes a “reasonable use” test for solo-regulated firms, while the PRA would retain “reasonably unforeseen” for PRA functions. |
| Enhanced firm thresholds | The FCA would raise thresholds for consumer credit, asset management, intermediary and wholesale markets firms. Mortgage and CASS Large thresholds would remain unchanged. |
The proposals contained in Phase 2 could significantly reduce the administrative burden of SM&CR, in many ways, a welcome change for regulated firms. However, they also result in a shift towards greater responsibility for competence, suitability and accountability to firms’ own judgement and governance.
The FCA and PRA propose abolishing the Certification Regime, which requires firms to identify certification staff, assess their fitness and propriety before appointment and annually, issue certificates and obtain regulatory references in prescribed circumstances.
The FCA also proposes retiring its Directory of Certified and assessed persons.
Although firms may welcome the proposed reduction in regulatory burden, they should not lose sight of their continuing responsibility for staff competence, suitability and conduct. FCA requirements, including competent-employee rules, Conduct Rules and relevant qualification requirements, would continue, as would professional qualification and Statement of Professional Standing requirements for relevant advisers. In the absence of a formal certification regime, the FCA expects firms to comply with these obligations through their standard employer practices, including recruitment monitoring, performance management, employment checks, referencing (for relevant roles) and training.
The PRA also proposes extending its competent-employee rule to cover honesty and integrity.
Further the FCA is considering extending relevant competence and suitability guidance to insurers, managing agents and the Society of Lloyd’s.
The FCA recognises the risks of removing the Certification regime and seeks views on retaining some or all certification requirements for certain of the eight current Certification functions, regulatory-reference requirements for particular roles, or elements of the Directory. It does not intend to consult again if it decides to retain or amend any of these requirements.
Regulatory references would no longer be required for Certification staff, but would remain for SMF applicants, including applicants for notified roles.
Firms would instead be able to use ordinary employment references and other checks when assessing suitability.
This materially simplifies recruitment below SMF level but gives employers greater discretion—and potentially greater responsibility—over what checks are appropriate. It is not clear how the removal of regulatory references for Certified staff will address the concerns the FCA have previously expressed, regarding the risk of “rolling bad apples” within the sector. This proposal also sits at odds with the recent focus placed by the FCA on requiring firms to address issues of Non-Financial misconduct (NFM).
The Conduct Rules would remain central to the regime, but the FCA proposes a less prescriptive approach. Rather than mandatory training, firms would tell staff which rules apply to them and the consequences of a breach, with discretion over how to do this. For example, they could integrate Conduct Rules requirements into wider induction, compliance or conduct communications and processes. However, firms may wish to be cautious about removing all training regarding these rules, which could send a message to employees that these rules are no longer important.
The FCA also proposes raising the reporting threshold for firms – with the intention of reducing the regulatory burden of reporting – by limiting reporting to breaches involving more serious misconduct for non-SMF staff:
The PRA proposes retaining the Individual Conduct Rules for Key Function Holders, Material Risk Takers and relevant credit-union roles. Reports would be due within seven business days for a final written warning after appeal, suspension, dismissal, or reduction or recovery of remuneration.
The FCA also proposes simplifying the breach-reporting form, potentially including structured questions on non-financial misconduct, in addition to new guidance that firms would not need to determine whether lower-level misconduct is a Conduct Rule breach for reporting purposes unless the disciplinary action is reportable.
If implemented, the proposals could reduce the time firms spend assessing lower-level misconduct, and could allow for a more proportionate approach to investigations.
However, firms would still need to investigate properly, consider the appropriate disciplinary outcome and any other notification duties, such as Principle 11 or SUP 15, and keep a clear and defensible record of their assessment. The proposed changes also make the choice of disciplinary sanction more consequential, as the difference between a first and final written warning can determine whether the regulatory regime is engaged.
Investigations involving SMFs, serious misconduct, non-financial misconduct or potential systemic issues are therefore unlikely to become materially lighter.
For Enhanced solo-regulated firms, the FCA proposes making SMF5 (Head of Internal Audit) and SMF10–15 (inclusive) subject to notification-only requirements (rather than requiring regulatory approval, as under the current SM&CR). These include chairs of the Risk, Audit, Remuneration, Nomination and With-Profits Committees, and the Senior Independent Director. At dual-regulated firms, only SMF13 and SMF15 are FCA functions; the others are PRA functions.
The PRA proposes moving a broader set of roles to notification-only requirements: SMF6 (Head of Key Business Area), SMF7A (Notified Group Entity Senior Manager), SMF8 (Credit Union Manager), SMF11 (Chair of the Audit Committee), SMF20 (Chief Actuary) and SMF20A (With-Profits Actuary).
Key executive roles, including the Chief Executive, Chief Finance and Chief Risk functions, would remain subject to regulatory prior approval. Both regulators would also retain approval for SMF24 (Chief Operating Officer), reflecting the importance of operational resilience, cyber risk and technology oversight.
Firms and their prospective senior managers should be aware that the change to notification-only status would not lower regulatory standards or expectations. Notified SMFs would remain subject to the same accountability requirements as approved SMFs, including the Duty of Responsibility and Senior Manager Conduct Rules.
How would vetting and notification work?
The move from approval to notification, and the prospect of quicker appointments, may be an attractive outcome for firms. However, it would also place greater reliance on firms’ own appointment processes.
Prior to notifying the regulator, firms would assess a candidate’s fitness and propriety and complete relevant checks, including obtaining a regulatory reference, reviewing criminal records and preparing a Statement of Responsibilities (SoR), where applicable. Firms would need to be comfortable that their vetting, governance and record-keeping are sufficiently robust to support their appointment decisions.
Notifications could be submitted up to three months before the appointment. For immediate FCA appointments, notification would take effect when the FCA acknowledges receipt; advance notifications would take effect on the specified start date. Notified individuals would appear on the Financial Services Register, distinguished from approved SMFs.
The FCA expects to carry out limited automated checks, such as confirming the form is complete and the candidate is not prohibited.
Under the PRA’s proposal, notification would take effect on the later of the specified start date and the PRA’s acknowledgement. The notification would neither need to be copied to the FCA nor require the FCA’s consent.
The Senior Manager holding Prescribed Responsibility A (PR A) would be accountable for the firm’s vetting of SMF candidates. The FCA proposes clarifying this in PR A; the PRA would do so in its rules and guidance.
Both regulators would retain powers to require pre-approval for otherwise notified functions in exceptional circumstances, including governance weaknesses, concerns about fitness and propriety assessments, or a role’s prudential importance.
The FCA proposes to remove SMF18 (Other Overall Responsibility) and SMF22 (Other Local Responsibility). Firms would need to allocate their responsibilities to other Senior Managers, and ensure that the new owner has the correct authority, information and support to discharge the responsibility. The FCA expects changes to SYSC 26 and COCON to allow greater use of delegation and layered management structures.
For solo-regulated firms, the FCA proposes narrowing SMF7 (Group Entity Senior Manager). It would apply only where an individual both exercises significant influence over the regulated firm and performs a specified group or sub-group function: SMF1 (Chief Executive), SMF2 (Chief Finance), SMF4 (Chief Risk), SMF9 (Chair of the governing body), SMF16 (Compliance Oversight), SMF17 (Money Laundering Reporting Officer) or SMF24 (Chief Operations). The FCA estimates this would reduce the solo-regulated SMF7 population by about 40%.
The PRA would retain pre-approval for SMF7 individuals whose group roles correspond to specified senior functions, however it proposes creating SMF7A, requiring notification for other qualifying group-level roles.
Both regulators propose ending routine submissions of updated Statements of Responsibilities (SoRs) and Management Responsibilities Maps (MRMs) when responsibilities change, removing Form J. Firms would still submit a SoR with an SMF application or appointment notification and, where required, an MRM. Neither would be required where one individual performs all SMF roles.
The FCA proposes removing nine Prescribed Responsibilities (PRs), retaining only:
The PRA also proposes removing some PRs, including those relating to certification, PR allocation, training and induction, MRMs, and maintenance of the firm’s business model. It would retain other PRA and sector-specific responsibilities.
Whilst the proposed changes could simplify SM&CR governance, firms would still need to decide who is accountable for relevant activities, maintain current documents, retain superseded versions and provide them to the FCA on request. In respect of certain SM&CR documents, the FCA proposes six-year retention periods for most firms and ten years for some dual-regulated firms.
Both regulators propose extending the temporary cover period for submitting an SMF application or notification from 12 to 18 weeks. This could give firms greater flexibility when an SMF role is unexpectedly vacant, giving them more time to find a suitable candidate and reducing pressure to make a permanent application within a short period.
The FCA proposes replacing the “reasonably unforeseen” test with a “reasonable use” standard for solo-regulated firms and FCA functions at dual-regulated firms. The PRA would retain the “reasonably unforeseen” test for PRA functions and expect firms to submit any required application or notification as soon as possible. Different tests could therefore apply to roles within the same dual-regulated firm.
The FCA proposes raising the thresholds that determine whether some solo-regulated firms fall within the Enhanced tier.
Firm type | Current threshold after Phase 1 | Proposed threshold |
Consumer credit lenders | £130m revenue | £200m revenue |
Asset managers | £65bn AUM | £100bn AUM |
Intermediaries | £45m revenue | £75m revenue |
Wholesale markets firms | Significant SYSC firm | £750m assets (three-year rolling average) |
The mortgage threshold (10,000 outstanding mortgages) and CASS Large threshold would not change.
Firms falling below the revised thresholds could move from Enhanced to Core requirements, reducing certain governance and administrative obligations, although the FCA could still impose Enhanced requirements based on a firm’s size, complexity or market impact.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields