SM&CR Phase 2: Less Process, Same Accountability? The FCA and PRA’s Proposed Overhaul to the Senior Manager and Certification Regime

Estimated reading time: 12 minutes

Members of the Fox Williams financial services regulatory and employment teams have been reviewing the latest proposed developments in relation to SM&CR and reflecting on what these would mean for firms and individuals in the sector.

Introduction

On 22 October 2026, the FCA published CP26/37, setting out Phase 2 of its review of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR). At the same time, the PRA published CP14/26.

Building on the Phase 1 reforms introduced in April 2026, Phase 2 aims to reduce complexity and cost while preserving accountability. The FCA estimates annual compliance expenditures could fall by £229m (around 53%) from an estimated £434.5m.

These are consultation proposals, not final rules. Some of the more significant changes also depend on the Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 becoming law, which would give the FCA and PRA greater flexibility to set SM&CR requirements.

The consultations close on 22 January 2027.  Dual-regulated firms will need to consider both the FCA’s CP26/37 and the PRA’s CP14/26. Final rules are expected in H1 2027, with implementation provisionally anticipated in H2 2027. If the proposed changes go through, firms will need to ensure that their business lines are aware of the implications, and that Risk, Compliance, Legal and HR teams and functions update their internal policies and procedures accordingly. The proposals also raise wider cultural issues for firms to consider in terms of accountability and conduct.

The consultation papers are lengthy (for example, the FCA’s consultation paper runs to 73 pages, with an additional 352 pages of draft Handbook text, and invites responses to 27 questions).  The update below is therefore a broad summary – should you have specific questions, please reach out to your usual Fox Williams contact or one of the authors of this update.  The regulators’ webpages include details explaining how to respond to the consultations.

Key proposals at a glance

AreaKey proposals
Certification and DirectoryThe Certification Regime and FCA Directory of Certified and assessed persons would be removed.
For CRR and Solvency II firms, the PRA proposes extending its competent-employee rule to expressly cover honesty and integrity.
Regulatory referencesRegulatory references would no longer be required for staff certified under the current SM&CR, but would remain for SMF applicants, including notified roles.
Conduct RulesThe FCA would retain the rules, but replace mandatory training with a duty on firms to tell each person which rules apply to them. For staff subject only to the Individual Conduct Rules (ICRs), it also proposes narrower reporting thresholds and a 14-month deadline for reporting final disciplinary outcomes (after any appeal).
Senior Manager appointmentsCertain roles, which currently require regulatory approval under the current SM&CR would become notification-only. This includes the FCA’s SMF 5 and SMF10-15 and a broader list for the PRA, including SMF 6 and SMF7a.
The FCA would also remove SMF18 and SMF22, and narrow the scope of SMF7 for solo-regulated firms.
Prescribed ResponsibilitiesThe FCA would remove nine Prescribed Responsibilities, retaining three for Core and Enhanced firms, plus one additional responsibility for relevant Enhanced firms.
SoRs and MRMsUpdated SoRs and MRMs would no longer need to be filed with regulators routinely when responsibilities change; Form J would be removed.
Temporary SMF coverBoth regulators would extend temporary SMF cover from 12 to 18 weeks.The FCA proposes a “reasonable use” test for solo-regulated firms, while the PRA would retain “reasonably unforeseen” for PRA functions.
Enhanced firm thresholdsThe FCA would raise thresholds for consumer credit, asset management, intermediary and wholesale markets firms. Mortgage and CASS Large thresholds would remain unchanged.

 

Key takeaways

The proposals contained in Phase 2 could significantly reduce the administrative burden of SM&CR, in many ways, a welcome change for regulated firms. However, they also result in a shift towards greater responsibility for competence, suitability and accountability to firms’ own judgement and governance.

Practical steps firms can take now

  • Respond to the consultation paper(s) with your firm’s views as to the appropriateness of the proposals and how you see them working in practice – the regulators are particularly keen to learn of any likely unintended consequences of the proposed changes
  • Use the consultation period to prepare and consider how your business will be impacted
  • Consider whether the threshold changes could alter your firm’s categorisation
  • Review which SMF roles may be removed, move to notification or remain subject to pre-approval
  • Trace how accountability could shift under each regulator’s proposals. For SMF18, SMF22, group roles and the different PR lists, identify who would own each duty and what SoR or MRM changes may be needed, alongside any employment contract changes required
  • Review competence assessments, conduct reviews, training programmes and recruitment checks to determine whether they remain proportionate and useful for managing risk and evidencing good governance
  • Consider how best to evidence the rigour of appointment decisions without regulatory pre-approval
  • Consider what employment related documentation (and linked HR systems) would need to change/be updated (eg contracts, handbooks, appraisal processes, disciplinary processes).
  • Review and assess existing training programmes and consider whether to retain or adapt them

Specific changes proposed: 

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*