Estimated reading time: 3 minutes
Can a tenant underpay rent due and still validly exercise a break clause? The High Court’s recent decision in Sterling House suggests it can where the landlord’s own representations prevent it from relying on the rent shortfall.
Break clauses have traditionally been a highly contentious area and are often unforgiving, requiring various pre-conditions to be satisfied before a tenant can exercise their break right. A tenant’s failure to comply strictly with pre-conditions can leave them tied to a lease they had expected to end. Sterling House Ltd v International Baccalaureate Organisation (UK) Ltd [2026] EWHC 2680 (BP) highlights a trap for landlords too: what they say and do before the break date can undermine a later challenge.
In this case, the tenant’s break was conditional on no annual rent or insurance rent remaining outstanding at the break date, 23 February 2026. Annual rent was payable quarterly in advance, while insurance rent was payable on demand.
Before the break date, the tenant requested invoices for sums due. Instead of invoicing for the full quarter’s annual rent, the tenant was invoiced to the break date only, which fell mid-quarter. The tenant paid that invoiced amount before the break date.
At 3PM on the working day before the break date, the landlord also hand-delivered an insurance rent demand, which the tenant paid five days later (after the break date). The landlord then challenged the break on two grounds: the unpaid balance of the quarter’s rent and the late payment of the insurance rent.
The Court held that the landlord was estopped from relying on the annual rent shortfall. The rent invoice clearly represented the amount that needed to be paid for the break to take effect. The tenant had reasonably relied on that representation to its detriment and the Court found it would be unconscionable for the landlord to go back on it.
The Court also found that the landlord could not rely on the unpaid insurance rent as the tenant had not been given a reasonable opportunity to pay it, and concluded that the tenant had not delayed payment. The landlord’s claim was dismissed.
The decision is consistent with the established rules on rent payable in advance. In PCE Investors Ltd v Cancer Research UK [2012] EWHC 844 (Ch), which was considered in Sterling House, the tenant had to pay the full quarter’s rent to satisfy its break condition, despite the break falling partway through the quarter.
The difference in Sterling House was the landlord’s representation as to the amount payable, which gave rise to an estoppel.
This case serves as a stark warning for landlords and managing agents that their actions leading up to a tenant’s break can override a tenant’s technical non-compliance with break conditions.
A successful break depends on the lease’s wording – but the landlord’s communications can matter too.
If you would like to discuss the issues outlined in this article, please contact our team.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields