Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
When a commercial agency ends, the Commercial Agents Regulations provide the agent with an entitlement to two alternative termination payments: indemnity and compensation. Indemnity applies only where there has been an express election in the agency agreement for indemnity; otherwise compensation applies by default. The remedies proceed on different principles and can produce different results [see main article from agent law news April 2026].
The Regulations entitle an agent to compensation for damage suffered because its relationship with the principal has ended. The Regulations go on to identify two situations in which damage is particularly likely. The first is where termination results in the loss of commission which proper performance of the agency agreement would have generated for the agent while leaving the principal with substantial benefits connected with the agent’s work. The second concerns costs and expenses incurred on the principal’s advice which the agent has not had an opportunity to recoup.
Those provisions explain the purpose of compensation but do not supply a formula to calculate the compensation amount. The courts therefore had to decide what the relevant damage represents and how it should be measured. The governing authority is the House of Lords judgment in Lonsdale v Howard & Hallam Ltd.
Lonsdale concerned an agency for the sale of shoes. The principal’s brand was declining, commission had fallen and the principal eventually ceased trading. The agent argued for an approach influenced by the practice under French law of using two years’ gross commission. The House of Lords rejected the automatic adoption of that measure for the United Kingdom market.
The lead judgment was given by Lord Hoffmann. He treated the agent’s loss as the value of the agency of which the agent had been deprived by the termination in that the agent had lost the opportunity to continue the agreement and receive the income that proper performance would have produced. He considered therefore that the court must ask what a purchaser would reasonably have paid, at or immediately before termination, to take over that opportunity.
This hypothetical sale does not permit the court to construct an artificial commercial setting. As Lord Hoffmann put it, “All that is notional is the assumption that the agency was available to be bought and sold.” Everything else must reflect the circumstances then existing. The assessment must consider the agency’s prospects, the market for the principal’s products, the risks surrounding future income and the price of comparable businesses.
The first practical task is to estimate the sustainable annual earnings which the agency would have produced had it continued. Commission generated during the 12 months before termination is often the starting point, but it is not a compulsory accounting period. A longer average may be more reliable where results fluctuate; recent figures may deserve greater weight where sales show a settled direction. Exceptional orders, lost customers, product launches and known market changes may require adjustment.
The calculation uses net rather than gross earnings. A buyer would consider the overhead expenditure and labour needed to obtain the income. Deductions may include travel, premises, administration, IT, insurance, marketing support and other overheads properly attributable to the agency. Where the agent conducts several agencies, shared expenditure must be allocated fairly rather than charged wholly to the terminated relationship or ignored because it would have arisen anyway.
The same reasoning explains the deduction of a notional salary or labour cost. If the agency depended on an individual agent’s work, or on an employee responsible for the account, a purchaser would need to perform or fund that work. The allowance should reflect the time and functions required by the particular appointment, not an assumed full-time salary where it occupied only part of the agent’s week. Lord Hoffmann confirmed that net earnings are ordinarily relevant because they are what matter to a prospective purchaser.
Once maintainable net earnings have been identified, a multiplier converts the projected annual return into a capital value. It reflects matters not captured by one year’s profit, including customer demand, the principal’s financial position, dependence on particular products, the possibility of future termination, marketability, competition and the work or investment required from a buyer.
A number of reported judgments have applied multipliers in the region of four to five. This has led something of a market expectation to apply a multiplier of between 4 and 5 as the expected range for an agency which is growing or maintaining a profitable level of activity. But it is not a legal rule. The figure must emerge from the evidence concerning the business being valued. In one case the court reduced the proposed multiplier to reflect market conditions, business uncertainty and the cautious approach likely to be taken by the relevant purchaser.
The principal’s condition at termination can alter the outcome materially. A profitable brand with credible growth prospects may support a stronger forecast and higher multiple. Falling demand, weak finances, obsolete products or approaching closure will reduce what a purchaser would offer. Lonsdale illustrates the limiting case: an agency tied to a business which had ceased trading had little or no future income stream to sell. Long service and established customer relationships cannot create value where future sales are likely to be absent.
Regulation 18 excludes an entitlement to compensation where the principal terminates because of an agent’s default which would justify immediate termination under general law. It also covers termination by the agent (subject to specified exceptions) and transfer of the agency to another person with the principal’s agreement. Separately, the agent must notify the principal within one year after termination that the entitlement will be pursued.
Compensation is a valuation of the commercial opportunity removed from the agent, using the information and risks present at the termination date. Evidence concerning sustainable earnings, attributable costs, labour requirements, and business prospects will usually determine the entitlement.
Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:
"*" indicates required fields