Introducer, agent, or broker: are intermediaries protected?

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Who is an agent?

Where a judgment refers to an intermediary as an “introductory agent” but also as an investment introducer and by analogy refers to the services provided as those of a broker, what is to be made of the legal status of the intermediary? When it comes to the entitlement to remuneration and the protections which are given by law, legal status matters.

When there is no – or seemingly no – contract, legal status can matter even more.

This was highlighted in the recent High Court judgment in DMA Resources Ltd v Brazilian Nickel Ltd which also serves as a reminder as to the different types of intermediaries which exist.

DMA Resources Ltd v Brazilian Nickel Ltd

DMA acted as an investment introducer in the mining and energy sector. Its business was introducing capital.

Brazilian Nickel operated a nickel mining project in Brazil.

DMA and Brazilian Nickel had entered into a number of consultancy and intermediary agreements over several years which provided for DMA to be paid commission for introducing investors. Importantly, none of the agreements entitled DMA to commission for introducing Resource Capital Funds (“RCF”), an investor. More importantly RCF had previously declined to invest in the Brazil nickel project.

In 2020, DMA engaged in conversations with RCF about investor interest in the Brazil nickel project. Mr Oxley, the CEO of Brazilian Nickel, was aware of these discussions. He told DMA that it did not need to be involved as Brazilian Nickel was likely to do a full equity deal with RCF. In August 2021, RCF entered into a formal investment agreement with Brazilian Nickel – in effect the full equity deal. DMA subsequently invoiced Brazilian Nickel for commission in respect of the introduction. In response Brazilian Nickel denied that any binding agreement existed covering the transaction that ultimately had occurred.

DMA commenced proceedings against Brazilian Nickel claiming that it should be entitled to receive commission or an introduction fee for the reintroduction of RCF to Brazilian Nickel.

The central issue before the Court was that DMA had no contractual entitlement to commission for the introduction of RCF. In deciding whether DMA was entitled to commission it would have been different had DMA been acting as a commercial agent or, possibly, a broker.

A commercial agent

If DMA had qualified as a commercial agent, Regulation 6 of the Commercial Agents Regulations would have saved the day. This is because Regulation 6 provides that in the absence of any agreement as to remuneration between the parties, a commercial agent will be entitled to remuneration common in that industry or, in the absence of common industry practice, reasonable remuneration. The result of this is that DMA would have been entitled to an amount equal to that common in the industry.

But DMA was not a commercial agent. It did not have “continuing authority” which is critical for being a commercial agent given that the Regulations define a commercial agent as “a self-employed intermediary who has continuing authority to negotiate the sale or purchase of goods on behalf of another person (‘the principal’), or to negotiate and conclude the sale or purchase of goods on behalf of and in the name of that principal”.

In passing it should be noted that whether an agent has “continuing authority” has been decided by the High Court to be determined at the time the agreement was made provided that such authority is not subsequently withdrawn. In DMA v Brazilian Nickel, Mr Oxley had expressly withdrawn any “continuing authority” DMA might have had when he informed DMA that it no longer needed to remain involved in discussions with RCF.

In addition to lacking “continuing authority”, DMA was involved in introducing investment instead of introducing third parties in respect of the “sale or purchase of goods”. Whilst under English law “goods” extends to some software and also to electricity, and gas (and the laws of many EU member states make no distinction between goods and services), DMA could not qualify as a commercial agent.

A broker?

The role of a broker was contrasted with that of a commercial agent in W Nagel (a firm) v Pluczenik & Ors where the court considered the interpretation of the Regulation which provides that the Regulations do not apply to “commercial agents who operate on commodity exchanges or in the commodity market”.

In this case the Court of Appeal made clear that a “commodity exchange” is the trading of commodities that can be freely brought and sold among participants. The Court of Appeal went on to contrast the trading activity performed by Nagel, whose work involved maintaining relationships and goodwill between parties in the diamond market, and the role of a broker simply being that of executing anonymous trades on a commodity market.

Set apart from commercial agents and brokers, an introducer’s role is generally limited to bringing parties together. DMA’s role in this case was limited to approaching investors and receiving commission for any capital brought in. Therefore, the role of DMA was that of an introducer.

But as an introducer without a contractual entitlement to any commission, did DMA have any claim to a payment?

A claim without a contract

Ordinarily an introducer would not be entitled to commission unless it had a contractual entitlement. In the absence of contractual entitlement, the Court decided that the correct approach to determining whether DMA had a claim to the amount it had earnt was by refence to the principles of unjust enrichment. As DMA had provided a service to Brazilian Nickel by re-introducing RCF, subsequently causing RCF to invest in the Brazil nickel project, it would have been unjust for DMA not to be remunerated for that service.

Take home point

As DMA Resources v Brazilian Nickel demonstrates the need for the parties to be clear about the role, an intermediary is performing is critical.

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*