When boilerplate bites: hidden dangers or opportunities in template termination rights

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

It is a story all too common for suppliers: a key customer is being supplied under a long-term arrangement when the relationship between the parties begins to break down.

The nature of the breakdown is such that the supplier has acquired the right to terminate the agreement, but crucially, it does not know that it has this right yet. More particularly the supplier will benefit from a termination payment – but only if the agreement is terminated in a certain way.

The supplier carries on performing the agreement and supplying the customer. But eventually the customer decides to give notice to end the agreement and, in turn, the recurring revenue on which the supplier had based its future plans and forecasts.

So if a supplier finds itself in this situation, is that it? Has it lost the right to terminate (and therefore the termination payment) because it carried on performing the agreement (which would usually be the case)? Or does the supplier still have the right?

URE Energy Ltd v Notting Hill Genesis

At the end of last year the Court of Appeal in URE Energy Ltd v Notting Hill Genesis suggested that the supplier might still have the right depending on:

  • how the terms of supply have been drafted in the agreement;
  • how much the supplier knew; and
  • how the supplier conducted itself.

The supply terms In URE Energy contained what the supplier thought to be a routine termination right for the customer’s insolvency. If the supplier could terminate under that right, it would benefit from a potentially substantial termination payment. However, the customer was not insolvent. In fact it was doing quite well, having recently amalgamated with another entity, and had told the supplier it had done so but crucially had not sought the supplier’s approval of the amalgamation which it was required to do under the terms of the supply agreement.

Unfortunately for the customer, the supplier took legal advice once the relationship had broken down. The supplier discovered that it had the right to terminate if the customer was subject to any amalgamation (not just an amalgamation where the customer had to do so because it was insolvent) if the customer had not got the supplier’s prior approval. The supplier served a notice to terminate the agreement and sought an exit payment linked to that termination right of almost £4m.

Following earlier decisions, the Court of Appeal decided that the supplier:

  • could terminate;
  • was entitled to the termination payment; and
  • was not prevented from relying on its termination right despite having continued to perform its obligations under the agreement for some months after it obtained the right to terminate.

The point (according to the Court of Appeal) was that the supplier did not know it had the right to terminate when it carried on supplying under the terms of the supply agreement but promptly sought to rely on the right once it had become aware that it had that right.

The result? The supplier obtained a substantial windfall of almost £4m as an exit payment.

A lesson and a warning

URE Energy Ltd v Notting Hill Genesis is both a lesson and a warning in careful drafting.

Check your standard terms of supply. Whilst the supplier was the beneficiary of drafting in URE Energy, these kinds of termination rights are more commonly drafted in a way which allows both the supplier and the customer to terminate for something happening which affects the other.

If the customer’s right to terminate is not carefully linked to the customer’s insolvency, the supplier’s terms of supply might gift the customer a right to terminate if it acquires a business, merges with another, or even receives outside investment.

On the other hand, if, as in URE Energy v Notting Hill Genesis, the termination right which deals with reconstructions or amalgamations affecting a party only benefits the supplier and not the customer, this can give the supplier an advantage if the relationship is breaking down.

The takeaways

Know your terms of supply.

Know when you can terminate a supply agreement. If you know that you have a right to terminate but carry on supplying under the terms of the supply agreement, you can lose that right! If you stop supplying but do not seek to terminate for some time, you may also be prevented from relying on that right.

If you do not know your supply terms, be careful! The Court of Appeal’s decision in URE Energy v Notting Hill Genesis is open to criticism. It follows that going forward you might not always be successful with an argument that you did not know that you have the right to terminate if it is expressly set out in your terms on which you supply!

Portfolio Close
Portfolio list
NameCVEmail
No one added to your portfolio yet.

Remove All

Download

Close

Exclusive Content

Unlock 24-hour access to our exclusive content including on-demand webinars by submitting your details using the form below:

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Agreement*